Spoiler warning: If you hold a reservation or plan to visit Alinea soon, please do not read any further. They serve a surprise menu here, and if you want to experience the full sensation, you should not know what is happening here.

Visited in August 2025
Dinner
Rating: Three Michelin Macarons

I had been planning to go here almost 10 years. A trip with Chicago as an intermediate station opened the opportunity for this. The reservation process via Tock was a little difficult because I did not know the time on the day when the reservation window opened for the desired date of my visit. So I missed the exact time and my preferred slot was booked out. An email to the restaurant with a request for a change resulted in a reply that, per evening, one reservation for a single guest is allowed and that the slots for reservation for one are booked out on the alternative days.
I stayed outside the town, so a train ride with the METRA Milwaukee District West and the red CTA line brought me to the restaurant in about one and a half hours.
The restaurant is inconspicuous from the outside. Inside, it is divided into different rooms. After passing the reception, we went up the stairs, crossed one room, and ended up in “The salon”. As mentioned above, the menu is a surprise menu. I ordered a bottle of 2022 Sancerre Sauvignon Blanc, Domaine Vacheron, Loire, France, as an accompaniment to the menu.
Remarkable: Gerolsteiner: as sparkling water.
A small mother-of-pearl spoon indicated a caviar course.

One was instructed to open the hand and the very nice dish, which resembled the surface structure of a pile of caviar, was placed into the hand. The course itself consisted of golden osetra caviar, pineapple custard, and a fingerlime, mescal infusion. Remarkable that pineapple and caviar pair well together and that you could clearly taste all the ingredients, even the mescal.

Next, a postcard with Chicago hot dog motive was placed onto the table. Remember: a Chicago hot dog never has ketchup on it. After a while, a petri dish with a jelly cube was placed on the postcard. Moustard, tomato, pickle, white onion, and a crispy mini-bun were the 5 colorful dots on top. The sausage taste was in the jelly. And believe it or not, this small cube had all the flavors you know from a hot dog – a small masterpiece!

Green fruits and vegetables were the topic of the next serving. The pieces and spheres were made of deskinned grapes, melon, kiwi, green olive, cucumber, and almond halves. It was topped with an open filo dough roll filled with almond crème. This was good. However, it fell slightly short in comparison with the first two servings.A fire cup was placed at the edge of the table and remained there during the next two courses.

A piece of arctic char, 5 days marinated, charred with a crispy skin, and nicely covered with caramelized maple syrup, was the next fantastic serving. After finishing, the beautiful platform was turned upside down, and a second serving with the same main ingredient was uncovered.

Under firm smoked custard was char roe in a slightly bound carrot emulsion. Again a nice idea and an absolute pleasant taste.

Quite impressive was the “dish” for the next course: a long branch with a coconut half. Inside was a small coconut preparation with a yellow disc on it. It revealed a scent of curry, lemongrass and a subtle spiciness. Good.

The next course played with temperatures of the same ingredient. It reminded me a little bit of the hot/cold tea I once had in The Fat Duck of Heston Blumenthal. The instruction for this very special dish was to pull the skewer, which had potato, truffle, and parmesan on it, out of the bowl and to immediately drink the whole composition. The two potato preparations were hot and cold.

Many different bowls, “plates”, and a bone were brought to the table for this “Argentinian archeological digging site”. Even tools were provided, and one got the task to expose two of the servings with a brush. Even the service helped digging: Out of the firecup in which the fire had now been extinguished, a small package was recovered. The package was cut open, and inside was a leaf that contained an additional serving, which had been cooked over the last courses. It added bitter tastes to the others. Both shrimp preparations were excellent, the dried flat complete shrimp and the preparation on the right on the main plate. The mayonnaise was spicy, the chimichurri very good, and the content of the bone, including marrow, was also an interesting, crispy mixture.

After finishing, I was asked as the only person in the salon to come down to the kitchen, where I spoke to the restaurant manager, and an additional course was served together with a drink pairing, which had Spain and paella as the topic. A far as I could overlook the kitchen, Grant Achaz was not present that evening.

Saffron rice from the pan was added onto a crispy disk with a mixture of different vegetables and seafood underneath. It was served with a drink made of bitter orange, saffron, gin and vermouth. Very good.

Back in the salon, the next course was exactly what I love so much: Perfection is not achieved when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing more to take away (Antoine de St. Exupery). Raviolo, truffle, parmesan, Truffle emulsion – basta.
I jokingly said to the waiter, “That was so good, I’d like three more.” A short time later, three more ravioli appeared on the table.

That’s what I call true customer service :-).

Now it was time for the main courses. First, pigeon breast and leg meat were served with crispy fried endive leaves, strawberry and a strawberry-infused jus. As a side dish, something that resembled a strawberry but was actually made of wax, strawberry juice, and chocolate, was presented.

The last savory course had fantastic tender inside and crispy outside wagyu as the main ingredient. Sides were Japanese eggplant, crispy seeds including pine nuts, Hokkaido turnip, and a red peach gel. The whole plate was topped with the grated ginger sweet potato tower, which can be seen in the first picture.

The pre-dessert was a sphere of goat milk filled with elderflower juice in a watermelon pink peppercorn emulsion. Aleppo is presumably the kind of pepper that was used here.

Now the final show started, which I knew from some reviews that I read years ago about this restaurant – the painting of the dessert directly onto the table. Everything was removed from the table, and the table was covered by an aseptic rubbery tissue. Various bowls and plates were set up at the head of the table. A cook painted the dessert in the following sequence: blueberry snow, white chocolate, then white chocolate thyme crème, blueberry jelly, marinated blueberries, a blueberry cake, candied oats, a chocolate ice cream cup, liquid nitrogen, and finally, the cup was smashed. Besides the spectacle, it tasted very good.

As an additional gimmick, a helium-filled balloon was provided with the goal of inhaling the contents of the edible balloon and then speaking like Mickey Mouse. This, of course, does not make much sense for a single person, but the other couples and multi-person parties had a lot of fun.

Summary

What a show, so much taste. To be honest, I was skeptical before my visit. But three macarons in Guide Michelin mean something, and that promise was completely fulfilled here. Besides this, the service was very warm and nice, and I did not miss one thing. This restaurant is an absolute recommendation for a one-time visit. I expect it to be repetitive because I guess that the menu is quite static.

Website: Alinea